National Library of New Zealand - Te Puna Mātauranga O Aotearoa Services to Schools - Supporting literacy and learning

Create Readers

We want to help create motivated and engaged young readers. This blog is about children's and YA literature (especially New Zealand), literacy research, and ways to get, and keep, kids reading.

Edge of Nowhere

Swept overboard ,Seth begins a gruelling four month journey home along the harsh Alaskan coast.

Salmon fishing off the unpredictable Alaskan coast, a violent storm and a 16 year old distracted by grief and resentment. These are the precursors to an epic survival story which is highly readable but not in the league of 'Hatchet' and 'The Cay'. Attempting to retrieve his dog,Tucker, Seth is swept overboard and miraculously manages to swim to one of the hundreds of islands dotted along the coast. His journey back home begins, leapfrogging from island to island encountering and overcoming every obstacle a good survival story should offer. Smelcer's Aleutian background and local knowledge add interesting detail but the pace is slow and events repetitive and a lot of time is spent on introspection. References to ancestors are understandable but didactic ''the power of myths does not require steadfast belief in the story: that is the realm of religion' (p.119). For a reading age 9-12 and an audience of young boys particularly, this is weighty and offputting.

Based on true events it is worth recommending to fans of survival and adventure stories. John Smelcer is a prolific author as well.

Andersen Press  ISBN 9781849391962  2010

Flickr image by slabshaft 

1 response to "Edge of Nowhere "

Anonymous (not verified) says:

I feel sorry for this reviewer, who seems so caught up in modern commercial soundbytes that he says this nove is slow because it doesn’t have outrageous action every page. I’m sorry that this reveiwer thinks that literature for young readers should have noting to teach them about life, that books for middle schoolers and young adults should be about farting dogs. We read great literature precisely because there is something important to take away from the experience. From what I’ve read, this story was basd on true events. I’m sorry being marooned on an island couldn’t be more exciting for this reveiwer.

Post new comment

will not be published